Vergleichen: Birnen mit Äpfeln?

PowerShot G2/EOS 350D.

 

Porównanie: pierniki z wiatrakami?

PowerShot G2/EOS 350D.

 

Deutsch

Polski

Seit gestern (24.03.2005) habe ich nun die frische EOS 350D. Da ich auch noch die PowerShot G2 besitze, hier einige Vergleichsfotos. Ja... ich weiß, die beiden Kameras kann man eigentlich nicht vergleichen... Auflösung 4 MPx bei der G2 und 8 Mpx bei 350D, G2 eine 4 Jahre alte Kompakte und 350D die neueste Hightech Spiegelreflexkamera, wenn ich nur zwei der Unterschiede nennen soll. Der Preisunterschied ist heute (der 25 März 2005) ziemlich groß - die neue EOS 350D kostet ca. 1000 Euro, die G2 bei Ebay (benutzt) ca. 150-200 Euro.

Die G2 ist gegenüber die EOS 350D sehr sehr langsam. Die Qualitätsunterschiede in den Fotos rechtfertigen allerdings den Preisunterschied nur bedingt. Meine G2 hat bis dato ungefähr 20-30 Tausend Fotos gemacht - leider hat sie aufgehört, sich mit einem externen Blitzgerät zu verstehen. Die EOS 350D ist mir noch sehr frisch und ich muss noch lernen mit der Neuen umzugehen.

Unter den Fotos die Exif-Informationen direkt aus den Originalaufnahmen. Ein Klick auf ein Foto holt das Originalbild, die Größe variiert... von ca. 2MB bei der G2 und 3,5MB bei der 350D.

Artur Rysch

Jestem od wczoraj (24.03.2005) posiadaczem świeżego EOS 350D. Jako, że posiadam również PowerShot G2, tutaj kilka zdjęć porównawczych. Tak, wiem, że obu apraratów nie można ze sobą porównać... 4 Mpx przy G2 i 8 Mpx przy 350D, G2 4 lata na rynku, natomiast 350D najnowsza hightech lustrzanka, jeśli nazwać tylko dwie różnice. Różnica w cenie wynosi na dzień dzisiejszy (25 marzec 2005) sporo - nowa EOS 350D kosztuje jakieś 1000 Euro, G2 w Alegro (używana) jakieś 150-200 Euro.

G2 jes naprzeciw tej EOS 350D bardzo bardzo wolna. Różnice w jakości zdjęć tłumaczą różnicę w cenie tylko warunkowo. Moja G2 zrobiła dotychczas 20-30 tysięcy zdjęć - niestety przestała się rozumieć w dodatkową lampą błyskową. EOS 350D jest dla mnie bardzo świeża i muszę się jeszcze uczyć z nią obchodzić.
 

Poniżej zdjęć Exif-informacje bezpośrednio o oryginalnych fotografii. Klik na zdjęcie sciągnie plik oryginalny, wielkość waha się... od 2MB przy G2 do 3,5MB przy 350D.

Artur Rysch

 

 

PowerShot G2

EOS 350D

Original date/time: 2005:03:25 15:18:11
Exposure time: 1/8
Shutter speed: 1/8.00
F-stop: 8.0
Focal length: 18.8125
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 6.0000
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:25 15:18:11
Modified date/time: 2005:03:25 15:18:11
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Digital zoom ratio: 1.0000
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 100
Canon quality: Superfine
Canon flash mode: Not fired
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: Single
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: Normal
Canon saturation: Normal
Canon sharpness: Normal
Canon ISO: Auto
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: Auto
Canon AF point: Center
Canon exposure mode: Av-priority
Canon long focal length: 672
Canon short focal length: 224
Canon focal length units: 32
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 4.095000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware Version 1.10
Canon image number: 2393931
Canon owner name:
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon PowerShot G2
X resolution: 180.0000
Y resolution: 180.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
File source: DSC
Original date/time: 2005:03:25 15:18:24
Exposure time: 1/1.25
Shutter speed: 1/1.25
F-stop: 22.0
ISO speed: 100
Focal length: 46.0000
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 8.9189
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Exposure program: Aperture priority
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:26 15:18:24
Modified date/time: 2005:03:26 15:18:24
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 100
Canon quality: Fine
Canon flash mode: Not fired
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: One-shot
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: High
Canon saturation: High
Canon sharpness: High
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: 2
Canon AF point: 0
Canon exposure mode: Av-priority
Canon long focal length: 55
Canon short focal length: 18
Canon focal length units: 1
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.000000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware 1.0.1
Canon serial number: 330139084
Canon owner name: unknown
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
X resolution: 72.0000
Y resolution: 72.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
   

PowerShot G2

EOS 350D

Original date/time: 2005:03:25 18:47:56
Exposure time: 1/1.67
Shutter speed: 1/1.68
F-stop: 8.0
Focal length: 18.8125
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 6.0000
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:25 18:47:56
Modified date/time: 2005:03:25 18:47:56
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Digital zoom ratio: 1.0000
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 100
Canon quality: Superfine
Canon flash mode: Not fired
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: Single
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: Normal
Canon saturation: Normal
Canon sharpness: Normal
Canon ISO: Auto
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: Auto
Canon AF point: Center
Canon exposure mode: Av-priority
Canon long focal length: 672
Canon short focal length: 224
Canon focal length units: 32
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: -0.001000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware Version 1.10
Canon image number: 2393953
Canon owner name:
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon PowerShot G2
X resolution: 180.0000
Y resolution: 180.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
File source: DSC
Original date/time: 2005:03:25 18:46:16
Exposure time: 25/10
Shutter speed: 2.50
F-stop: 20.0
ISO speed: 100
Focal length: 52.0000
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 8.6439
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Exposure program: Aperture priority
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:26 18:46:16
Modified date/time: 2005:03:26 18:46:16
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 100
Canon quality: Fine
Canon flash mode: Not fired
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: One-shot
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: High
Canon saturation: High
Canon sharpness: High
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: 2
Canon AF point: 0
Canon exposure mode: Av-priority
Canon long focal length: 55
Canon short focal length: 18
Canon focal length units: 1
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.000000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware 1.0.1
Canon serial number: 330139084
Canon owner name: unknown
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
X resolution: 72.0000
Y resolution: 72.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
   

PowerShot G2

EOS 350D

Original date/time: 2005:03:26 07:14:45
Exposure time: 1/60
Shutter speed: 1/59.97
F-stop: 2.2
Focal length: 12.5000
Flash: Fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 2.2813
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:26 07:14:45
Modified date/time: 2005:03:26 07:14:45
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Digital zoom ratio: 1.0000
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 0
Canon quality: Superfine
Canon flash mode: Auto
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: Single
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: Normal
Canon saturation: Normal
Canon sharpness: Normal
Canon ISO: Auto
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: Auto
Canon AF point: Center
Canon exposure mode: Program
Canon long focal length: 672
Canon short focal length: 224
Canon focal length units: 32
Canon flash activity: Fired
Canon flash details: 8192
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 2.014000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware Version 1.10
Canon image number: 2393963
Canon owner name:
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon PowerShot G2
X resolution: 180.0000
Y resolution: 180.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
File source: DSC
Original date/time: 2005:03:26 07:16:01
Exposure time: 1/60
Shutter speed: 1/60.00
F-stop: 5.0
ISO speed: 400
Focal length: 37.0000
Flash: Fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 4.6439
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Exposure program: Normal
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:27 07:16:01
Modified date/time: 2005:03:27 07:16:01
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 0
Canon quality: Fine
Canon flash mode: Auto
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: AI Focus
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Full auto
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: High
Canon saturation: High
Canon sharpness: High
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: 2
Canon AF point: 0
Canon exposure mode: Easy shooting
Canon long focal length: 55
Canon short focal length: 18
Canon focal length units: 1
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 8200
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.000000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware 1.0.1
Canon serial number: 330139084
Canon owner name: unknown
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
X resolution: 72.0000
Y resolution: 72.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
   

PowerShot G2

EOS 350D

Original date/time: 2005:03:26 11:07:13
Exposure time: 1/125
Shutter speed: 1/125.26
F-stop: 4.0
Focal length: 7.0000
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 4.0000
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:26 11:07:13
Modified date/time: 2005:03:26 11:07:13
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Digital zoom ratio: 1.0000
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 0
Canon quality: Superfine
Canon flash mode: Auto + Red-eye
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: Single
Canon image size: 5
Canon easy shooting mode: Full auto
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: Normal
Canon saturation: Normal
Canon sharpness: Normal
Canon ISO: Auto
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: Auto
Canon AF point: Center
Canon exposure mode: Easy shooting
Canon long focal length: 672
Canon short focal length: 224
Canon focal length units: 32
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: -0.001000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware Version 1.10
Canon image number: 2393972
Canon owner name:
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon PowerShot G2
X resolution: 180.0000
Y resolution: 180.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
File source: DSC
Original date/time: 2005:03:26 11:06:40
Exposure time: 1/200
Shutter speed: 1/200.00
F-stop: 8.0
ISO speed: 400
Focal length: 21.0000
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 6.0000
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Exposure program: Normal
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:27 11:06:40
Modified date/time: 2005:03:27 11:06:40
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 0
Canon quality: Fine
Canon flash mode: Auto
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: AI Focus
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Full auto
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: High
Canon saturation: High
Canon sharpness: High
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: 2
Canon AF point: 0
Canon exposure mode: Easy shooting
Canon long focal length: 55
Canon short focal length: 18
Canon focal length units: 1
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.000000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware 1.0.1
Canon serial number: 330139084
Canon owner name: unknown
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
X resolution: 72.0000
Y resolution: 72.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
 
Nun ein Portrait meines Sohnes - leider ist es
mir nicht gelungen, aus der gleichen Perspektive
zwei Fotos zu machen - jeder, der ein 5-jähriges
Kind erlebt hat weiß, wovon ich spreche :-)))
A teraz portret mojego syna - niestety nie udało
mi się, z tej samej perspektywy zrobić
2 porównywalne zdjęcia - każdy, kto miał do
czynienia z 5-letnim dzieckiem, wie o czym mówię.

PowerShot G2 mit internem Blitz

EOS 350D mit internem Blitz

Original date/time: 2005:03:27 10:01:53
Exposure time: 1/60
Shutter speed: 1/59.97
F-stop: 2.8
Focal length: 10.6875
Flash: Fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 2.9688
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:27 10:01:53
Modified date/time: 2005:03:27 10:01:53
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Digital zoom ratio: 1.0000
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 0
Canon quality: Superfine
Canon flash mode: On
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: Single
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: Normal
Canon saturation: Normal
Canon sharpness: Normal
Canon ISO: Auto
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: Auto
Canon AF point: Center
Canon exposure mode: Program
Canon long focal length: 672
Canon short focal length: 224
Canon focal length units: 32
Canon flash activity: Fired
Canon flash details: 8192
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.819000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware Version 1.10
Canon image number: 2404025
Canon owner name:
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon PowerShot G2
X resolution: 180.0000
Y resolution: 180.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
File source: DSC
Original date/time: 2005:03:27 09:33:09
Exposure time: 1/60
Shutter speed: 1/60.00
F-stop: 5.0
ISO speed: 400
Focal length: 33.0000
Flash: Fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 4.6439
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Exposure program: Normal
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:28 09:33:09
Modified date/time: 2005:03:28 09:33:09
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 0
Canon quality: Fine
Canon flash mode: Auto
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: AI Focus
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Full auto
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: High
Canon saturation: High
Canon sharpness: High
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: 2
Canon AF point: 0
Canon exposure mode: Easy shooting
Canon long focal length: 55
Canon short focal length: 18
Canon focal length units: 1
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 8200
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.000000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware 1.0.1
Canon serial number: 330139084
Canon owner name: unknown
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
X resolution: 72.0000
Y resolution: 72.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
   
Nun ein Versuch, ein Makro zu erstellen. Die G2 habe
ich auf Makro-Stellung gehabt, was aus der
Entfernung von ca. 60cm etwas zu weit ist für ein
Makro. Die EOS350D bräuchte wiederum bei der
Entfernugn schon ein Makro-Objektiv,
ich habe aber nur das Standard-Objektiv
EFS 18-55mm. Der Test hier ist also nicht richtig
representativ.
A teraz przykład makro. G2 nastawiłem na makro,
jednak te 60cm to właściwie trochę za dużo na
makro. EOS350D potrzebuje z tej odległości raczej
objektyw makro, ja dysponuję obecnie objektywem
standardowym EFS 18-55mm. Ten test nie jest
więc całkiem reprezentatywny.

PowerShot G2

EOS 350D

Original date/time: 2005:03:28 08:20:56
Exposure time: 1/1.67
Shutter speed: 1/1.68
F-stop: 8.0
Focal length: 12.5000
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 6.0000
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Spot
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:28 08:20:56
Modified date/time: 2005:03:28 08:20:56
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Digital zoom ratio: 1.0000
Canon macro mode: Macro
Canon self-timer: 100
Canon quality: Superfine
Canon flash mode: Not fired
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: Single
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: Normal
Canon saturation: Normal
Canon sharpness: Normal
Canon ISO: Auto
Canon metering mode: 1
Canon focus type: Close-up
Canon AF point: Center
Canon exposure mode: Av-priority
Canon long focal length: 672
Canon short focal length: 224
Canon focal length units: 32
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.657000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware Version 1.10
Canon image number: 2404054
Canon owner name:
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon PowerShot G2
X resolution: 180.0000
Y resolution: 180.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB
File source: DSC
Original date/time: 2005:03:28 08:15:38
Exposure time: 16/10
Shutter speed: 1.60
F-stop: 16.0
ISO speed: 100
Focal length: 38.0000
Flash: Not fired
Exposure mode: Auto
White balance: Auto
Orientation: Top-left
Aperture: 8.0000
Exposure bias: 0.0000
Metering mode: Pattern
Exposure program: Aperture priority
Digitized date/time: 2005:03:29 08:15:38
Modified date/time: 2005:03:29 08:15:38
User comment:
Custom rendered: Normal
Scene capture type: Standard
Canon macro mode: Normal
Canon self-timer: 100
Canon quality: Fine
Canon flash mode: Not fired
Canon drive mode: Single
Canon focus mode: One-shot
Canon image size: Large
Canon easy shooting mode: Manual
Canon digital zoom: None
Canon contrast: High
Canon saturation: High
Canon sharpness: High
Canon metering mode: Evaluative
Canon focus type: 2
Canon AF point: 0
Canon exposure mode: Av-priority
Canon long focal length: 55
Canon short focal length: 18
Canon focal length units: 1
Canon flash activity: Not fired
Canon flash details: 0
Canon G1 focus mode: Single
Canon white balance: Auto
Canon burst sequence: 0
Canon subject distance: 0.000000
Canon flash bias: 0.000000
Canon firmware version: Firmware 1.0.1
Canon serial number: 330139084
Canon owner name: unknown
Camera make: Canon
Camera model: Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
X resolution: 72.0000
Y resolution: 72.0000
Resolution unit: Inches
Colorspace: sRGB